BY CHARLES COSTELLO
If you’ve attended games at Rose Hill this year, and if you’ve bothered to look at the attendance figures put out by the university, you know the numbers are a bit misleading. Anyone who has gone to a game can see the empty student section or the half empty reserved sections. But that’s not the full story. There’s also the constant complaining, the defeatist words and attitude, the criticism of players, coaches, and administration. You see, my problem with Fordham fans is separated into two categories: The students, for not showing up at games. And the alumni, for the negativity and criticism that they spew. Let me describe in greater detail a problem that has plagued the Fordham community since the men’s and women’s programs joined the Atlantic 10 back in 1995.
The Students
For some home games this year (Princeton, James Madison, New Hampshire), no students showed up. Yes, they were played during Thanksgiving and Christmas breaks, but as I’ve said in the past, Fordham is a local school, and thus, many students live nearby and can easily drive or take the train in. If they cared about their team, and wanted to show their support, they’d make an effort to get to the games. Even when students have been on campus, attendance has been poor. With the exception of opening night against Columbia and the following Saturday against Manhattan, student attendance has been pathetic. We’re really only talking here about games against Lafayette on Monday Dec. 8 and Fairfield on Thursday Dec. 11, when the student section was not even filled to one third of its capacity.
Now, I have to give credit to the students who have shown up. They’re enthusiastic, full of energy, and supportive. Good fans all around. But there’s not enough of them. The Rose Hill Gym holds 3200 people. The bleachers to the side of the visiting team’s bench are reserved for students. There have been far too many occasions where fans of the visiting team sitting behind their bench have outnumbered the students sitting behind the basket to their right. Inexcusable.
The big test is now here with the Atlantic 10 season beginning tonight. Given the history of student attendance, with students not moving back to campus until Sunday, I wouldn’t expect much tonight against St. Bonaventure, or even Sunday against Xavier, the No. 16 team in the country. But for games against Duquesne, Saint Louis, UMASS, Rhode Island, Richmond, and Saint Joseph’s, I would hope the student section would be filled to capacity. Hope, not expect.
The Alumni
Fordham University is blessed to have some of the most successful, generous, and active alumni in the country. From broadcasters to businessmen to politicians, the roll call of noted alumni is impressive, just take a look at pages 157 and 158 of this year’s men’s basketball media guide. If you’re a Fordham student or an alum and you need inspiration, career guidance, or support, you have it, perhaps better than at any other school in the country. And I mean it. I have a great deal of respect for Fordham alumni. They’re a family, and families stick together.
So, then, why have they abandoned their team? At games, you can see it in their body language, hear it in their words, and feel it as soon as you walk into the Rose Hill Gym. At home, you can read it on the message boards. You often sense that they don’t like this team. They don’t think the players are Atlantic 10 players, they don’t think the coaches know their X’s and O’s, and they don’t believe the administration A) has what it takes to win, and B) wants to win.
Here’s my defense of the team, coaches, and university:
The players are young and inexperienced, but they’re talented basketball players, and if you watch them on a game to game basis it’s obvious they’re getting better. Jio Fontan may be the best point guard we’ve had here at Rose Hill by the time he graduates, and there are other young and developing players like freshman Alberto Estwick, sophomore Mike Moore, and junior Herb Tanner, who have shown promise. Sophomore Jacob Green is just getting going and Brenton Butler, before he got hurt, was looked upon as a go-to-guy. Add the inside presence of Chris Bethel and the leadership of Luke Devine and you have some pieces here. And don’t forget about the recruits coming in next year. Be honest, this coaching staff has shown an ability to recruit good basketball players and solid citizens.
As for the coaches, to criticize them on their X’s and O’s, while I understand this is what fans do, isn’t really fair. First, they’re coaching a young team and young players who are going to make mistakes, going to have bad nights and growing pains, and who need time to develop. And how is it fair to criticize a head coach, Dereck Whittenburg, who has been involved in college basketball as a player and coach since 1979. A coach who won a championship with North Carolina State in 1983. A coach who has experience playing for championship coaches like Morgan Wootten and Jim Valvano. Don’t you think he knows something about this game? Don’t you think that something is a whole lot more than you know?
And then there’s the administration, from Fr. McShane (President) to Jeffrey Gray (Student Affairs) to Frank McLaughlin (Athletic Director). It’s mind boggling that alumni criticize these three for their lack of commitment to the team and facilities. Do you realize how much money they spend on the basketball team each year, how much money big time college athletics costs? And they’ve shown a commitment, from joining the Atlantic 10, to renovating the Rose Hill Gym, to hiring coaches who are getting paid a decent sum, to showing up at games. What more do you want them to do? You want a new arena? We can talk about that one but the bottom line is you need the money, and in this economy with the capital projects Fordham has taken on in the past, this isn’t as easy as it seems. As for saying the administration doesn’t care about the program? Totally unfair. By the way, it cost two million dollars back in 2002 to renovate the arena.
By the way, Whittenburg has said nothing but positive things about the alumni and the support they give to his team.
The Challenge
Most fans tell me that when the team wins they’ll show up. To me, that’s pretty lame, but I understand that’s how fans work. When I was growing up in the 1980s and my dad would take me to Yankee Stadium there would be 15,000 there a night to see Rickey Henderson, Willie Randolph, Don Mattingly, and Dave Winfield. Why? Because they weren’t winning, certainly not like they win today. Once the winning came and October baseball returned to the Bronx the place was sold out.
But here at Fordham we don’t have that kind of time. We have a game tonight against St. Bonaventure, the start of the Atlantic 10 season. I think it’s safe to assume that the student section will be empty, at least empty in terms of students in attendance. Hard for me to understand, but I’ve followed this team for too long to expect anything different.
So that leaves it up to the alumni. What do you say we sell out the reserved seats on both sides of the court, and fill up the section to the left of the Fordham bench behind the basket, and put a few to the right of the visiting bench on the opposite end. Give me 2700 tonight at Rose Hill and I’ll stop complaining about your complaining, at least for now.
And people who think I’m obsessed with this attendance thing are going to love this next comment: I’m more excited to see how many people show up Sunday, and who those people are, than I am about the game with No. 16 Xavier, the best team to come to Rose Hill this year. With students moving back on to campus Sunday, and given their apathy when it comes to Fordham basketball, you can’t count on them to fill the place.
But that’s where the alumni come in. You, the alumni, must fill the student section and every other nook and cranny of the Rose Hill Gym. I expect a complete sellout on Sunday, 3200 to see the Rams and Muskateers. You sell that game out and I’ll leave you alone. At least until the next home game.
High Praise for Fordham from Xavier’s Sean Miller
Posted by Fordham SportsNet on January 12, 2009
Xavier head coach Sean Miller is a big supporter of the job Dereck Whittenburg is doing at Fordham, saying after yesterday's game at Rose Hill that the Rams' head coach is building a winning program in the Bronx. Miller also praised freshman point guard Jio Fontan and his teammates. (Photo taken by Keith Krebs, courtesy of Joe DiBari)
BY CHARLES COSTELLO
Fordham fans have been waiting 14 seasons now for their team to become an Atlantic 10 contender, one that consistently wins year in and year out. As a result of the Rams’ struggles over the years to make it to the top of the conference, a wave of criticism, second guessing, and general impatience has emerged from the team’s fans.
For those starving for a winner at Rose Hill, Xavier head coach Sean Miller provided some perspective yesterday when talking about Fordham in his post game comments after the 16th-ranked Muskateers defeated the Rams, 86-60, in a hard-fought battle in the Bronx.
“I think they (Fordham) have a lot of good young players that are skilled,” Miller said. ”They pass the ball, dribble the ball, and they have the ability to shoot from a number of different spots. They’re that scary team, especially on their home floor, that in a given night - they made 10 three’s tonight - against maybe some other teams that don’t have some answers like we do, that could have been enough to win the game. It seems like they’re really executing their offense better and better as the year goes on. I’m sure with a young team they’ll keep getting better on defense.”
Miller was particularly impressed with freshman point guard Jio Fontan, a player who is quickly making a name for himself at the college level.
“Fordham, to me, is very difficult to guard with Jio Fontan at the point,” Miller said. ”He’s an incredible point guard, a freshman who I believe is as talented as any guard that’s playing college basketball as a freshman. He means a lot to their team. I watched him play a lot in AAU in high school. He’s an excellent player. Fordham’s future is very bright with him in the program.”
And Miller, unprovoked and totally on his own accord, saved his biggest praise for Fordham head coach Dereck Whittenburg.
“Dereck Whittenburg is doing a really good job,” Miller said. ”From day one he’s lost six seniors. I don’t think anyone in the county has lost more seniors or more quality minutes than he did. This is his second turn with it now. These younger players will get older and have more success as they do.”
Posted in Football Commentary, Men's Basketball | Leave a Comment »